Search This Blog

Friday, October 9, 2015

What's wrong with our schools? - Here is a clue - “The philosophy of the school room in one generation will be the philosophy of government in the next”



Horace Mann (1796-1859) is seen as the father of American Education.  Mann had little formal education as a youth, gaining a lot of his early education by reading books at the town library, where he learned enough to be admitted to Brown University.  After graduation in 1819, he taught for a while, studied law and then entered politics, where he soon became a rising star in the state assembly. Between 1837 and 1848, Mann became the best-known educator in America, and the best-known American educator throughout the world.
To the diversity of social and economic status, Mann wanted to introduce the "common school"; that is, a school common to all the people that would provide a common and unifying experience.  Mann wanted to eliminate the religious and class distinctions implicit in this dual system.  Mann saw the school system as a promulgator of class distinction where the students would be pitted against one another by their difference in curriculum in the schools.  The common school would be commonly supported, commonly attended and commonly controlled; its ultimate goal would be sociological and national unity. 
On the surface, this seemed good-natured but as we see now, that we are in the future, this has allowed the sociological to overpower the educational fundamentals.
Mann's faith was total.  There were no restrictions, at least in his mind, to what the common school could do.  He believed that the traditional curriculum could be universalized, and that culture, previously reserved for the upper classes, could be democratized or fairly balanced.  In 1837, to the surprise of those around this rising star of the state assembly, Mann was appointed secretary to the board of education.  Through his post on the board, he influenced the educational system not only of the state of Massachusetts but also of the entire United States.  The basic skills of reading, writing and arithmetic were just the start; over the decades, society has assigned many other skills previously learned in the homes to be taught in schools.  Now we have the secular and morally dysfunctional “Department of Education”.  Although the board’s powers were limited at the time, it was able to affect public opinion regarding school problems.  Mann's only instrument was the Annual Report he wrote, Mann’s 12 annual reports when he was the secretary to the Massachusetts board of education are a record in which he set forth his vision of what education should be in a free society.  This strongly influenced the evolution of modern education by meeting educational needs.
Mann, as a result of his scholastic agenda, was then elected to the United States House of Representatives to fill the vacancy caused by the death of John Quincy Adams, where he served until 1853.
In Mann’s 12th annual report, the culmination of the series, Mann contemplates the demise of the educational system in America.
“And hence it is that the establishment of a republican government, without well-appointed and efficient means for the universal education of the people, is the most rash and fool-hardy experiment ever tried by man. Its fatal results may not be immediately developed,--they may not follow as the thunder follows the lightning,--for time is an element in maturing them, and the calamity is too great to be prepared in a day; but, like the slow-accumulating avalanche, they will grow more terrific by delay, and, at length, though it may be at a late hour, will overwhelm with ruin whatever lies athwart their path. It may be an easy thing to make a Republic; but it is a very laborious thing to make Republicans; and woe to the republic that rests upon no better foundations than ignorance, selfishness, and passion.”
Mann goes on to say that a republic may grow in numbers and in wealth; its armies may be invincible and its military power may strike fear in the heart of nations around the world, but if the Republic of America is “devoid of intelligence” it will eventually “rush with the speed of a whirlwind to an ignominious end”.
Mann also adds this to his contemplation of an ignorant United States of America.
“However elevated the moral character of a constituency may be; however well informed in matters of general science or history, yet they must, if citizens of a Republic, understand something of the true nature and functions of the government under which they live.  That any one who is to participate in the government of a country, when he becomes a man, should receive no instruction respecting the nature and functions of the government he is afterwards to administer, is a political solecism ( a mistake).”
Mann knew the dangers of introducing the constitution to the classroom without a common and proper teaching platform, because of the different renderings citizens held of the constitution.  He feared that teachers and instructors would be chosen on account of their party affiliation: “or that teachers will feign affinities which they do not feel”.  Given the chance teachers would invent ways to look attractive to those that are heading the school boards and even teach falsehoods in which they do not even believe in so that they would be kept or hired. Mann also knew that if the “tempest” of political strife were let loose on the “Common Schools”, ‘they would be overwhelmed with sudden ruin.”  The schoolroom is a theater for party politics and Mann wondered with “what violence will hostile partisans struggle to gain possession of the stage, and to play their parts upon it!”  Mann’s solution was to elect prudential; committees in each state that would make the political decisions for the school, thus taking the fight out of the schools and placing them in the streets and at the ballot box.  This reasoning demands that the school districts would be responsible for their own political viewed school and course of study.  This of course gave the Federal government the opportunity after the Civil War, during the Reconstruction period to take on a larger role in public education, attempting to ensure Southern States would rectify the inequalities caused by slavery.  The lines between public and private remained blurred much longer in higher education than in elementary schooling mainly for the reason that the elementary and secondary schools funding was provided by local money and a closer look by school boards and parents controlled what the local schools were teaching.

Previous to the Civil War, it had been planned to expand college attendance.  The Morrill Act of 1862* established land-grant colleges enabled this to happen. By 1867, just after the Civil War and during the period of reconstruction the House of Representatives created the Education and Labor Committee.  Congress first authorized the Department of Education along with the US Office of Education in 1867, eight years after the death of Horace Mann and thirty years after his appointment to the position of secretary of the board of education of the state of Massachusetts.  The department was just supposed to collect and disseminate information on education.
I find it interesting that all of these committees and departments were enacted almost 30 years to the date after Horace Mann’s acceptance of the seat on the Massachusetts Board of Education.  30 Years allows for a total of three sets of students to finish the 10th grade.  So, it might be safe to say that there were some of Mann’s educated graduates that had been elected to Congress by that time.  Since this gave a generation of instruction to students and the student’s children, it only follows that there were those that grew up learning the thoughts of Mann and permitted this style of education to become stronger and more developed.  As Lincoln said, “The philosophy of the school room in one generation will be the philosophy of government in the next”.


* Morrill Land Grant Act gave to each state the proceeds from the sale of 30,000 acres of public land for each member it had in Congress.  The money went to support vocational college courses in agriculture and the mechanical arts.  In some instances, established colleges added these vocational courses, but in most cases, new colleges were founded.

No comments:

Post a Comment

BE NICE. No bad language and no racial or age discriminating language.